← All concepts · Chapter 2 guide
The Contingency View: It Depends
There is no one best way to manage. The right structure, leadership style, or control system depends on the situation: the technology, the environment, the size of the organization, and the people. The goal is the best fit, not the best practice.
A tight, rule-based style works in an operating room or a nuclear plant. The same style smothers a creative agency, where loose structure and autonomy fit better.
What about this situation should change how I manage it?
Copying what worked somewhere else. A practice that fits a startup can fail in a hospital, and the reverse.
Name one management practice your workplace copied from somewhere else. Does it fit your situation, or was it borrowed because it was popular?
Is 'it depends' a cop-out answer on an exam?
Show the answer
Only if you stop there. A strong answer says what it depends on (environment, task, people, size) and which choice fits which conditions.